Miss Claire MCProfine 24/7 Waterproof Eye Pencil Eyeliner

Very disappointed. The Taupe shade does not transfer onto the waterline. I tried to apply it, but there was only a clear water line... and bits of pencil flew into my eye! I had to dry the waterline with a cotton swab and remove the pencil layer with a tissue before it transferred! And it still didn't transfer fully on the first try. I can't even begin to describe how many times I went over my waterline with it and how much my eyes hurt afterwards. I used to want to buy all the shades of this pencil, but I will never purchase any eyeliner from Miss Claire again.